The National Post is Canada’s second largest national paper.
Regulators have approved a giant expansion of an oil sands project proposed by Royal Dutch Shell PLC – but included an unprecedented list of warnings about the negative impacts on the environment and on Aboriginal communities.
While finding the 100,000-barrel a day expansion of Shell’s Jackpine mine is in the public interest based on economic benefits, the panel, representing the Alberta Energy Regulator and the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, dedicated large parts of its 405-page ruling to the cumulative environmental costs, some of them irreversible.
The takeaway: With the oil sands industry under growing public scrutiny, the regulators are signalling they are not willing to take responsibility for broader societal choices and want governments to step up and take the heat for them.
“Politicians have used regulators to insulate them from the political aspects of ongoing development, and it would appear that this ruling is saying: ‘This is going to be a political decision and we need direction’,” said David Yager, national leader, oil field services, at MNP LLP, in Calgary.