Barrick Gold’s chair lauds Glencore over BHP as a mining model – by Liesel Hill and Simon Casey (Mail and Guardian – May 1, 2014)

http://mg.co.za/

In an exit interview, Barrick Gold’s founder Peter Munk has said Glencore Xstrata’s boss is going to “eat them all”.

Ask Peter Munk, the founder and former chairperson of Barrick Gold Corporation, whom he most admires in the mining industry, and you get a passionate, digressive response, along with a possible clue to the direction of the world’s largest gold producer.

“What Ivan Glasenberg has done equals an Olympic record,” Munk said last week in an interview, referring to the billionaire chief executive at Glencore Xstrata Plc.

It was Glasenberg who led Glencore’s 2013 takeover of Xstrata Plc, the biggest in mining. Munk, who is 86 and retired at Barrick’s annual shareholder meeting in Toronto on Wednesday, says he’s good friends with the Glencore boss and admires his ambition to compete with the biggest miners, such as Rio Tinto Group, BHP Billiton and Vale SA.

“He’s taken Xstrata, he’s now very close to the BHP Billitons, he’s going to eat them all,” Munk said. Munk’s comments are being scrutinised particularly closely after failed merger talks between Barrick and Newmont Mining Corporation degenerated this week into a public dispute between both miners.

Read more

As Munk ‘steps down’, Barrick Gold records 90% plunge in profits – by Dorothy Kosich (Mineweb.com – May 1, 2014)

http://www.mineweb.com/

“You can take, maybe, Munk out of Barrick, (but) you can’t take Barrick out of Munk,” Peter Munk told Barrick shareholders at the company’s AGM Wednesday.

RENO (MINEWEB) – Anyone who thinks Peter Munk’s influence will no longer play a major role at Barrick Gold as he retired as co-chairman of the board Wednesday was in for a rude awakening as Munk told shareholders at the company’s annual general meeting that he intends to remain “very involved in Barrick.”

Munk’s son Anthony Munk was re-elected to the Barrick Board of Directors with 94.1% of the shareholder vote. Peter Munk will retain an office at Barrick corporate headquarters in Toronto.

As he departed from the Barrick board, Munk predicted Wednesday his greatest investment for Barrick over the past 32 years will be new Chairman of the Board John Thornton.

During Munk’s tenure as CEO, chairman, and co-chairman over the past 32 years, Munk said Barrick twice earned more money than any mining company in Canadian history, paid $8 billion in taxes, and created 25,000 jobs in 20 countries. However, along with Munk’s overall success as a CEO and chairman of Barrick, have come some staggering losses.

Read more

Peter Munk’s bittersweet goodbye to Barrick – by Rachelle Younglai (Globe and Mail – May 1, 2014)

The Globe and Mail is Canada’s national newspaper with the second largest broadsheet circulation in the country. It has enormous influence on Canada’s political and business elite.

Peter Munk, a Hungarian refugee whose ambitions led him to build hotels in the South Pacific and create stereos for Frank Sinatra, said goodbye to Barrick Gold Corp., the company he founded three decades ago and turned into the world’s biggest gold producer.

The 86-year-old Canadian businessman stepped down as the company’s chairman on Wednesday, a bittersweet moment for Mr. Munk, who has described Barrick as his life and the one thing that keeps him up at night.

“You can take, maybe, Munk out of Barrick. You can’t take Barrick out of Munk,” he said at the company’s annual meeting of shareholders in Toronto.

Mr. Munk knew nothing about gold mining when he took a stake in a small mine near Wawa, Ont., in 1983. He spent the next 30 years buying out rivals and building Barrick into a gold giant.

He has been succeeded by former Goldman Sachs executive John Thornton, who he says shares his vision of transforming Barrick into a Canadian-based mining titan with production in all types of metals.

Read more

Peter Munk says he’s leaving Barrick Gold in good hands – by Lisa Wright (Toronto Star – May 1, 2014)

The Toronto Star has the largest circulation in Canada. The paper has an enormous impact on federal and Ontario politics as well as shaping public opinion.

Outgoing founder and chairman praises management team and new board chair amid tough times in the gold industry in emotional farewell at annual meeting.

Gone, but definitely not forgotten. That was the tone of Barrick Gold Corp.’s annual meeting in Toronto Wednesday, which marked the emotional farewell of outgoing chairman and founder Peter Munk, and the release of dismal first quarter financial results amid the lacklustre gold price.

The auditorium was filled with the requisite Bay St. suits and shareholders while the annual group of environmental protesters outside hoisted a 15-foot Munk puppet and waved signs like “Gold is a toxic asset” to mark the 86-year-old’s departure.

But it was really Munk’s show, in which he made a farewell speech that drew laughs, hugs, kisses and a standing ovation for his 30 years at the helm of the firm that began as a penny stock with one mine in Northern Ontario to the world’s largest gold miner.

“As much as we’d like to believe we are eternal, the reality hits home,” he said. “The time has come to hand it over.”

Read more

Gabriel may seek billions in arbitration over stalled Romanian mine – by Eric Reguly (Globe and Mail – April 30, 2014)

The Globe and Mail is Canada’s national newspaper with the second largest broadsheet circulation in the country. It has enormous influence on Canada’s political and business elite.

The Toronto mining company whose 15-year effort to open Europe’s biggest gold project has gone nowhere is preparing an international arbitration case against the Romanian government that would seek billions of dollars in damages.

Gabriel Resources is making plans for the case, which probably would be heard in Vienna in the second half of the year, as it starts to wind down its activities in Romania’s Transylvania region to conserve cash. About 400 employees, or 80 per cent, of Gabriel’s Romanian subsidiary, Rosia Montana Gold Corp. (RMGC), have been suspended at three-quarters pay. The company has said it may fire them in May “if there is no progress in the advancement of the project.”

Gabriel, which is listed on the Toronto stock exchange but run from London, is not expecting a breakthrough any time soon. The Romanian parliament’s chamber of deputies is scheduled to vote on a bill that would give special legal status to the $1.5-billion (U.S.) project, allowing it to go ahead, on May 7.

But the company does not expect the vote to go in its favour, partly because public opposition to the mine and its cyanide-based extraction technology remains strong.

Read more

Peter Munk’s career comes to end as Newmont firestorm envelops Barrick – Peter Koven (National Post – April 29, 2014)

The National Post is Canada’s second largest national paper.

It wouldn’t be in Peter Munk’s nature to go out quietly. But no one expected this.

As Mr. Munk, 86, officially retires at Barrick Gold Corp.’s annual meeting on Wednesday, he does so in the midst of an appalling public feud between Barrick and Newmont Mining Corp., which went from eager merger partners to mortal enemies in a matter of days. It will take years to rebuild the bridges between these companies, if indeed that ever happens.

Mr. Munk was not closely involved in the Newmont negotiations — he left that to his hand-picked successor John Thornton. But he still found a way to stick himself in the middle of the dispute. In a detailed interview with the Financial Post last week, just as talks were collapsing, he ripped Newmont’s corporate culture and said the company is “not shareholder friendly.” Newmont was not amused.

Remarkably, that was one of the less incendiary things Mr. Munk said about his U.S. rival over a lengthy conversation that touched on many aspects of his career. He has always spoken his mind and never worried too much about what people think of it. But as his time in Canadian business comes to a close, he was even more candid, thought-provoking and entertaining than usual.

For example, if Newmont didn’t like the “not shareholder friendly” line, it certainly won’t appreciate his description of how Barrick found its flagship gold mine and became the dominant player in Nevada:

Read more

Barrick needs a deal maker, not a deal breaker – by Boyd Erman (Globe and Mail – April 29, 2014)

The Globe and Mail is Canada’s national newspaper with the second largest broadsheet circulation in the country. It has enormous influence on Canada’s political and business elite.

Barrick Gold Corp. co-chairman John Thornton has laid out a vision for creating a diversified miner – a vision that is going to be more difficult to realize after a nasty end to talks in his first major transaction.

Mr. Thornton has stated he wants Barrick to be a leader “in a range of minerals.” To do that, he is going to have to be a buyer, adding companies that produce other metals to complement Barrick’s output of gold and copper. So it’s all the more problematic that would-be merger partner Newmont Mining Corp. singled out Mr. Thornton as a particular obstacle to getting a deal done. Even if it’s not true (and it’s hard to know what is fact in any such situation), the statement is out there now and will be attached to Mr. Thornton’s name.

Negotiations break down all the time, between all types of companies. But rarely do supposedly secret talks spill into the public sphere quite so comprehensively as they have in the past week, as seemingly every detail of the talks between Barrick and Newmont landed in the press. Since the first reports that merger talks between the two had hit a snag, the premium, the timing, the consideration, the executive structure and other key terms all made their way to the press even though neither side ever publicly confirmed the negotiations.

Read more

Barrick-Newmont merger collapses into toxic war of words – by Peter Koven (National Post – April 29, 2014)

The National Post is Canada’s second largest national paper.

TORONTO — A much-anticipated merger between Barrick Gold Corp. and Newmont Mining Corp. has collapsed into a toxic public feud between leaders of the two firms that simply could not get along.

Talks between the two companies are finished, and sources said there is no chance they will start again anytime soon. That is bad news for shareholders, who stood to benefit if the miners combined their highly complementary Nevada operations.

It would have been the biggest deal in the history of the gold mining sector. Its failure demonstrates that clashing personalities can destroy a transaction that seemingly makes sense in every other way.

The two firms have tried to merge numerous times over the years, but personality clashes got in the way each time. This time was no different, though this was as close as they ever got to a deal. Newmont initiated the latest round of negotiations.

“They’re like two kids in the sandbox,” said John Ing, president and gold analyst at Maison Placements Canada. “The logic of the merger is there, but when you get down to board seats and personalities, it’s a different kettle of fish.”

Read more

COMMENT: Newmont, Barrick talks dead -by Marilyn Scales (Canadian Mining Journal – April 28, 2014)

Marilyn Scales is a field editor for the Canadian Mining Journal, Canada’s first mining publication. She is one of Canada’s most senior mining commentators.

Even when a merger is no longer on the horizon, the two sides still disagree. Such is the case as Toronto’s Barrick Gold issued a terse press release this morning to say that talks of a merger with Newmont Mining of Denver have been terminated at Newmont’s request.

That might have been the end of it, but Newmont released the text of an April 25, 2014, letter from chairman Vincent A. Calarco to Barrick co-chair John L. Thornton. Newmont said it had been hopeful that the two companies could merge and realize their combined strengths. However, over recent weeks the talks had become adversarial rather than oriented toward a mutually beneficial partnership.

“Our board,” wrote Calarco, “has met a number of times since we were twice told definitively last Thursday by your co-chairman that the process in which we had been engaged to find a basis to merge our two companies was ‘dead’. As you would expect, that unilateral declaration made us question whether we actually shared the vision and values that are necessary to forge a successful new company.”

Unsaid, but understood, is that Newmont is pointing the finger at Thornton.

Read more

The meaning of Peter Munk – by Peter C. Newman (MACLEAN’S Magazine – April 28, 2014)

http://www.macleans.ca/

As the notorious magnate leaves Barrick Gold, Peter C. Newman contemplates his rise, fall, and what’s next

With Peter Munk about to abandon his chairmanship of the Barrick mining empire at next week’s annual meeting in Toronto, it seems only appropriate to dwell on his fall from grace. From being the invincible king of international gold mining, the pride of Canada’s business tycoonery, the talented Mr. Munk finds himself accused of having moved too far, too fast, at too high a cost—¬leaving his company stuck with a tricky salvage operation.

But that is not the guts of the story, not the sum total of this remarkable mega-entrepreneur’s long journey from his aristocratic Hungarian background to at least three excursions into commercial glory. That sequence of initiatives climaxed in his successful run as the world’s champion gold magnate, who until the past three years could do no wrong. The dramatic reversal of his standing on Bay Street brought into play British explorer George Leigh Mallory’s 1924 comment about Mount Everest. When asked why he risked his life climbing the mountain, he famously replied: “Because it’s there.” Sixty-four years later, on Sept. 29, 1988, when Stacy Allison became the first American woman to conquer the great peak, was asked the same question, she smiled and shot back: “Cause I’m here!”

That’s the essence of Peter Munk, explained in three words: ¬the optimistic, fast-action guy, convinced that everything he touched would turn to gold. For most of the past five decades that was pretty well what happened. His company was flying high and he dominated its annual shareholders’ meetings, rhetorically armed to meet any challenge. It was at these public performances that he shifted into high gear, using messianic hand gestures and commanding body language. Inevitably, he won over his audiences.

Read more

Barrick Gold says Newmont Mining ends merger talks – by Rachelle Younglai (Globe and Mail – April 28, 2014)

The Globe and Mail is Canada’s national newspaper with the second largest broadsheet circulation in the country. It has enormous influence on Canada’s political and business elite.

Barrick Gold Corp. said on Monday that Newmont Mining Corp. has decided to end their merger talks, a development that could lead Barrick to launch a hostile bid for its American rival.

The Toronto-based Barrick had been trying to renew talks with Colorado-headquartered Newmont last week, a source had said. But Newmont’s board of directors decided to “terminate” their discussions, Barrick said.

“Although Barrick believes the interests of shareholders are best served through the completion of this business combination, Newmont’s board has determined that the interests of Newmont’s shareholders are best served by remaining independent,” Barrick said in a statement. Newmont had no immediate comment.

The companies, the world’s two largest gold producers, have discussed merging at least two other times over the last two decades.

The rout in the gold industry led to their recent discussions, with the miners identifying about $1-billion in cost savings.

Read more

Big-name lawyer takes on Ontario’s law society [Bre-X and Joe Groia] (MACLEAN’S Magazine – April 27, 2014)

http://www.macleans.ca/

Judges said that Joe Groia was “unprofessional” in his successful defense of Bre-X vice-president John Felderhof against fraud charges in the late 1990s

The Canadian Press – TORONTO – A prominent securities lawyer and the society that regulates the legal profession in Ontario are bound for court in the latest round of an epic battle started in the aftermath of the billion-dollar Bre-X mining fiasco in the late 1990s.

Closely watched by the legal profession, the contest pits Joe Groia, who successfully defended the only person charged in the history-making securities scandal, against the Law Society of Upper Canada.

“There have been few cases, if any, where the (society) has been so dogged and determined to maintain a position that was so damaging to the public and profession as a whole,” Groia argues in court documents.

How he behaved during the tumultuous Bre-X courtroom odyssey is what’s at issue. The society maintains Groia misbehaved to such an extent in defending Bre-X vice-president John Felderhof that he warranted a two-month suspension and ordered him to pay $247,000 in costs — reduced on initial appeal in March to one month and $200,000.

Read more

In destabilising economic war over Ukraine, gold the winner – by Lawrence Williams (Mineweb.com – April 25, 2014)

http://www.mineweb.com/

U.S. data and the escalating Ukraine crisis have seen gold Yo-Yo down and back up again.

LONDON (MINEWEB) – Some very volatile trading in gold and silver yesterday. The former dived to its lowest price since February to around the $1,270 mark before almost immediately rebounding sharply to a little below $1,300 before settling above $1,290, a position it held overnight.

Silver, living up to its more volatile general role at one stage dipped down below $19.00, its weakest level since its December lows before it too revived sharply jumping back to close the day at around the $19.60 level before settling back to around $19.55 where it was sitting this morning as Europe opened.

Analysts put the price movements to factors such as U.S. economic data, but in this writer’s view the downturn was largely due to a loss in confidence by traders in the prospects for short term precious metals price growth following gold and silver’s lacklustre performance as it drifted downwards – but then the recovery came on the back of the deteriorating situation on the ground in the Ukraine. Ukrainian forces started to move in to quell the demonstrations and government building occupations in the Donetsk region in the east of the country.

Read more

‘Exciting years’ for Lake Shore Gold – by Ron Grech (Timmins Daily Press – April 25, 2014)

The Daily Press is the city of Timmins broadsheet newspaper.

TIMMINS – Dan Gagnon held a captive audience of local business owners as he talked about the prospects of Lake Shore Gold’s “continuous improvement and growth” filtering down to the community.

“I think we’ve had an exciting couple of years, definitely a breakthrough year for us in 2013,” said Gagnon, who is Lake Shore Gold’s senior vice-president of operations. “We saw a steady increase in production. We started generating free cash flow, so we’re now a business that can fund its own projects … We’ve basically gone from 85,000 ounces a year in 2012, to 135,000 in 2013, to 160,000 to 180,000 (anticipated this year).”

Gagnon was the keynote speaker at a Timmins Chamber of Commerce luncheon held Thursday at the Schumacher Lions Den.

Asked if there were opportunities for small local businesses to prosper from the growth in operations at Lake Shore Gold, Gagnon replied, “Definitely. In 2012, for example, we spent $130 million locally. That was 60% of our spending which was basically local with all the suppliers that you see off Algonquin Boulevard. There is a big push for us to support the local, then the Northern and then Ontario.”

Read more

Peter Munk to leave Barrick Gold having seen its highs and lows – by James Wilson (Financial Times – April 24, 2014)

http://www.ft.com/home/us

Peter Munk started Barrick Gold with $40m of his own money in 1982, knowing not much about mining.

Now 86, and after more than 30 years in the gold business, Mr Munk still talks about Barrick having been the entrepreneurial “young upstart” for much of its life – but it became a company worth $50bn, a Canadian national champion built by a Hungarian-born refugee and the largest producer of gold in history.

Yet the past two years have been tough on Mr Munk, Barrick and the rest of the gold industry, particularly 2013, when Barrick posted $11.5bn of writedowns, cut its dividend and had to raise $3bn in equity to try to cut its debt.

“I would not have chosen this particular year as my final one as chairman, but I don’t get to write the script,” a chastened Mr Munk wrote in the company’s annual report. Barrick is now worth about $21bn.

Mr Munk also acknowledged the damage wrought by Barrick’s acquisition of Equinox Minerals in 2011. The unexpected diversification into copper came at an inflated price, for cash, and sparked doubts last year over Barrick’s debt levels and liquidity.

Read more