Beware Hasty, Unwise Policy Decisions After Mount Polley – by Kenneth P. Green (Huffington Post – August 12, 2014)

Kenneth P. Green – Fraser Institute Senior Director, Natural Resource Studies

The pictures coming out of northern British Columbia where the Mount Polley mine tailings pond ruptured on Aug. 4 are painful to see. The fact that the site is remote, and that only a small number of people are likely to be directly affected doesn’t mitigate the visceral pain one feels at seeing images of uprooted trees, and mud-clogged streams and rivers. Humans inherently find healthy ecosystems beautiful and degraded ecosystems painful.

One also has to sympathize with the people near Mount Polley, who have been (temporarily at least) told not to consume water from their local waterways, and who fear damages to salmon and other wildlife, and damages to their livelihoods that partly depend on tourism.

In the aftermath of such incidents, it’s normal to ask what can be done to prevent this from happening again, and indeed, such questions are not only normal, they are at the heart of how we learn as human beings.

But it’s one thing to seek to learn from a disaster and it’s another thing to incite emotional responses to promote hasty, unwise public policy actions. Despite the fact that virtually nothing was known about the cause of the Mount Polley leak, only two days after the spill, the David Suzuki Foundation had set up an automatic petition portal on their website calling on the provincial government to institute a moratorium on new mine approvals, a suggestion that would imperil a substantial part of BC’s economy. This is “ready, fire, aim” policy-making.

Last year in B.C., gross mining revenues were more than $8 billion, and employed over 10,000 British Columbians directly, at an average compensation (salary and benefits) near $115,000 annually. That’s only the direct employment; the B.C. government estimates 30,000 British Columbians work either directly or indirectly in the mining sector.

Over $500 million flowed into government coffers as a result of mining activity. Six per cent of aboriginals in BC work in mining and a great many of those are recruited to work from a state of unemployment. Mining accounts for over one-third of B.C.’s exports.

There is no evidence, at present, to suggest that what happened at Mount Polley is indicative of systemic risk that would justify the moratorium proposed by the Suzuki Foundation.

For the rest of this column, click here: